Tax implications of business legal structures

Dec 09, 2024 By Susan Kelly

The kind of entity will significantly impact your decision to start or restructure a business in terms of its tax implications. Your choice of business structure will affect your taxes, liabilities, and, subsequently, the bottom line. Each comes with advantages and challenges, whether from sole proprietorships to corporations. The following article will walk you through the tax considerations for different business structures, enabling you to make the appropriate decisions for your goals and minimize your tax burden.

Business Structure Overview and Tax Consequences

Determining the proper structure is an essential initial step in building a business, as it will have considerable consequences regarding your taxes. Each business classification has tax implications affecting your bottom line and financial planning.

Sole Proprietorship

Therefore, a sole proprietorship is the simplest form of doing business from a tax standpoint. You report your business income and expenses as a sole proprietor on Schedule C of your tax return. While simplicity is attractive, it also means you are personally liable for all business debts and obligations.

Partnerships

Like sole proprietorships, partnerships are pass-through entities. This means the actual business is not subjected to taxation. Instead, the profits and losses pass through to the partners, who report their share on their tax returns. While tax planning is advantageous, it relies on an elaborate record-keeping system and well-defined partnership agreements.

Corporations

Businesses have more intricate tax requirements. C-corporations are subject to corporate income taxation, while shareholders are levied on dividends; thus, the income is subject to double taxation. On the other hand, S-corporation owners have a pass-through tax liability, but their eligibility requirements are higher.

Limited Liability Companies (LLCs)

LLCs provide flexibility in taxation. Single-member LLCs are usually taxed as sole proprietorships, and multi-member LLCs can be taxed as partnerships or corporations, depending on how the business owners intend to maximize their tax position.

Tax Issues for a Sole Proprietorship

Personal and Business Income Combined

You will file personal and business income on your tax return as a sole proprietorship. You must file Schedule C (Form 1040), which reports the profit or loss from your company. Your business earnings are considered personal and taxed based on your tax rate. The positive about this is that it makes tax filing easier but can also place you into a higher tax bracket.

Self-Employment Tax Obligations

One significant consideration for sole proprietors is the self-employment tax. This tax covers your Social Security and Medicare contributions, typically split between employers and employees in other business structures. As a sole proprietor, you're responsible for both portions, totaling 15.3% of your net earnings.

Quarterly Estimated Tax Payments

Unlike employees whose taxes are withheld in every paycheck, sole proprietors make estimated tax payments quarterly. That, in turn, necessitates a high degree of budgeting and financial planning to ensure you set aside money to meet your estimated tax obligations throughout the year. The failure to pay may attract penalties as well as interest charges.

Deductions and Expenses

The positive side is that, as a sole proprietor, you can deduct most business expenses directly against your income. For example, you might need to buy office supplies, take business trips, and even deduct part of your home expenses if you have a home office. Detailed records are essential to maximize these deductions and lower tax liability.

Partnership Tax Filing Requirements

Filing taxes as a partnership can be confusing. If you are a partner, you need to understand some of the unique requirements and responsibilities that apply to you in a partnering business.

Form 1065: The Partnership's Return

A partnership must file an annual information return, Form 1065, which reports income, deductions, gains, and losses but does not calculate the tax due from the partnership. Rather, it reflects thorough information about the partnership's financial activities.

Schedule K-1: Share of Individual Partner

Each partner has a Schedule K-1 that reflects their share of the income, deductions, credits, and other items. As a partner, you'll need this information to report your partnership income on your tax return, Form 1040. It is vital to file this information correctly to avoid conflicts with the IRS.

Estimated Tax Payments

Unlike employees who have taxes withheld from their paychecks, partners generally must make quarterly estimated tax payments. These payments will cover both your income tax and self-employment tax. Failure to do so may be subject to penalties, so addressing this requirement is essential.

State and Local Tax Considerations

Remember state and local filing requirements. Most jurisdictions have separate filing requirements for partnerships, which differ from federal ones. Research and adhere to all state and local tax laws that apply to avoid potential problems at some point.

S Corporation Taxation Rules

Pass-through Taxation Benefits

S corporations provide unique tax benefits in the form of pass-through taxation. As a business owner, you will realize that the business entity doesn't pay federal income taxes. Instead, business profits and losses "pass-through" to the shareholders, who then report their share on individual tax returns. This can prevent the double taxation often presented with C corporations.

Shareholder Salary Considerations

Operating an S corporation requires you to pay yourself a reasonable salary, considering you're actively involved in its operation. The IRS carefully observes an S corporation owner's compensation to ensure their compensation is at market rates. You can optimize your tax situation by balancing your salary with distributions. Still, you should comply with the IRS guidelines to reduce potential audits or penalties.

Limitations on Shareholders

S corporations can have only a limited number of shareholders and certain types of shareholders. You may have at most 100 shareholders, who must be United States citizens or residents. Other corporations, plus most partnerships, cannot hold shares in an S corporation. This could impact your capital-raising options and limit your ability to take in investors. Consider your long-term objectives when you choose the form of organization.

Tax Filing for C Corporations

Under Double Taxation

One weird tax situation with the C Corporation is called "double taxation." That's because the corporation pays corporate income tax on its earnings, and then shareholders pay personal income tax on any dividend received. While it may sound rather disadvantageous, the inside of it should be understood.

Corporate Tax Rates

Starting in 2021, C Corporations will pay a flat federal corporate tax rate of 21%. As discussed below, all taxable income is taxed at this rate, regardless of the size or revenue of the corporation. It is worth noting that state corporate tax rates vary widely and will significantly affect your overall tax burden.

Shareholder Considerations

Shareholders of a C Corporation report their dividend income on their tax return. These dividends are usually taxed at a preferential rate, lower than ordinary income tax rates. Sometimes, in the case of high-income individuals, this will ensure lower overall tax burdens than that provided to the owners of pass-through entities such as S Corporations or LLCs.

Tax Planning Opportunities

Although carrying a double tax system, C Corporations enjoy some exclusive tax planning benefits. For instance, they can deduct more business expenses than other types of corporations, including health insurance premiums and employee benefits. What's more, C Corporations can hold earnings in reserve for future growth without immediately taxing their shareholders, allowing flexibility in cash management and strategic planning.

Conclusion

Setting up the proper business structure to control your liability tax liability is essential. Whether you decide on a sole proprietorship, a partnership, an LLC, or a corporation, each has ramifications for the taxes paid, some much more than others. Once you have the proper setup, you'll be well-situated to handle the complex world of business taxation and set up your enterprise for success.

Related articles
Questions with Amex Digital Labs’ VP and head of partnerships
Insights from Amex Digital Labs' VP and Head of Partnerships in this exclusive interview covering digital innovation, fintech trends, and strategic collaborations.
Susan Kelly Dec 04, 2024
Is Your Rental Property Eligible for Tax Deductions? All About Rental Real Estate Loss Allowance
Rental property loss? The Rental Real Estate Loss Allowance can help. Understand eligibility, benefits, and how to use it for tax savings
Georgia Vincent Dec 13, 2024
Reverse Mortgage Saver Program Explained: A Look Back at Its Purpose and Functionality
Curious about the Reverse Mortgage Saver Program? Discover what this financial tool was, how it worked, and why it appealed to retirees looking to access home equity with lower upfront costs.
Aldrich Acheson Dec 14, 2024
Tax Help for Seniors and the Disabled: Insights from IRS Publication 524
Explore IRS Publication 524 to understand the Credit for the Elderly or the Disabled, including eligibility criteria, income limits, and application procedures to maximize your tax benefits
Susan Kelly Dec 13, 2024
Tax-Smart Ways to Help Your Kids or Grandkids
Because of the persistent increase in the price of higher education, parents and grandparents need to set aside money for their children and grandchildren as soon as they are old enough to do so.
Triston Martin Feb 08, 2024
Qualified dividends: Inclusion in Gross Income and Tax Implications Explained
Find the role of qualified dividends in your gross income and how they impact your tax obligations. Understand IRS requirements, tax rates, and strategies to maximize after-tax returns.
Darnell Malan Dec 16, 2024
Your Guide to Electric Vehicle Tax Credits in 2024: What’s Changed
What's new with electric vehicle tax credits in 2024, including eligibility, changes in EV incentives, and how the latest federal policies make switching to clean energy vehicles more affordable
Triston Martin Dec 13, 2024
How Miscellaneous Tax Credits Can Lower Your Taxes: A Detailed Overview
How miscellaneous tax credits can help reduce your tax liability. Learn what they are, how they work, and explore examples of available credits to save money
Verna Wesley Dec 13, 2024
How to Begin Transferring Money Internationally
An international money transfer, better known as a remittance, is transmitting money across national borders from one country to another.
Georgia Vincent Dec 11, 2024