Dec 11, 2024 By Susan Kelly
When dealing with taxes, its not unusual to feel a little uneasy at the mention of the IRS examining a return. Many people dont realize they have rights and options when the IRS decides to look deeper into their tax filings. IRS Publication 556, Examination of Returns, Appeal Rights, and Claims for Refund, serves as a guide to help taxpayers understand what to expect if the IRS reviews their return, how to appeal decisions, and how to file for a refund if needed.
In this guide, we'll break down the steps and terminology involved in Publication 556 so that what seems like a daunting process will be much easier to approach.
The IRS examination process might help reduce a little of that fear. The IRS selects tax returns for examination, also called audit-ofttimes, using an algorithm that flags discrepancies and anomalies. Nevertheless, it doesn't necessarily mean you made a mistake. The audit might occur at random or through a mass check-up of IRS compliance.
Audits usually are either correspondence, done by mail, or field audits: in-person meetings that you have either at your place or in an IRS location. There is always a letter sent whenever the IRS initiates an audit, giving you a summary of what they are looking into and what documents they will be needing. You should collect receipts and records relevant to bank statements to support items on your tax return. Second, you have the privilege to represent yourself, and even this can be a CPA or enrolled agent so that your rights are adequately safeguarded. You are prepared for any examination process.
IRS Publication 556 describes the basic rights of taxpayers when being audited. There are known rights referred to as the Taxpayer Bill of Rights, which protects at all stages of dealing with the IRS.
Right to Privacy and Confidentiality: The IRS must treat your information with confidentiality. They are only allowed to ask for information relevant to the audit.
Right to Be Informed: You are entitled to know every detail of the process, including why the audit is conducted, what proof you are expected to provide, and the decision taken. The IRS is under a legal obligation to explain all the changes proposed to the tax liability imposed on you.
Right to Representation: At any point during the examination, you have the right to be represented by someone such as a certified public accountant, enrolled agent, or tax attorney.
Right to Appeal: If you disagree with the examination outcome, you have the right to appeal the decision within the IRS. Understanding these rights can help ease some of the stress surrounding an audit and provide clarity on how to respond.
Should you disagree with the IRSs findings after an examination, IRS Publication 556 lays out a clear process for appealing the decision. Heres a closer look at what you can do if you find yourself in this position.
The first step in the appeal process is to carefully review the IRSs findings. Once you understand why the IRS has made its decision, you have two main options: either file a protest letter to request an appeal or enter into a formal appeals conference. The protest letter needs to be detailed, listing every area of disagreement along with supporting documents or evidence for your position.
The Appeals Office is a separate and independent branch within the IRS, designed specifically to provide a fair review of disputed issues. During the appeals process, you may meet with an appeals officer who will examine both sides positions and try to come to an equitable resolution without taking the matter to court. This process can be less costly and faster than court proceedings and allows you to negotiate terms with some level of flexibility.
If you cannot reach an agreement through the IRS's appeals office, the next option is to take the case to the U.S. Tax Court. This route, however, involves a formal legal process and often requires a tax attorney, making it a more complicated and expensive approach.
Another critical area covered by IRS Publication 556 is how to file a claim for a refund. Taxpayers are eligible for refunds in cases where they have overpaid taxes, and Publication 556 outlines the steps to follow to ensure your claim is accurate and processed correctly.
To start the refund claim process, youll need to submit an amended return using Form 1040-X, along with any supporting documents justifying the claim. The IRS has strict deadlines for filing refund claims. Generally, you have three years from the date you filed your original return or two years from the date you paid the tax, whichever is later. Missing these deadlines can result in the IRS denying the refund, so its essential to adhere to these timeframes.
Once the IRS receives your refund claim, they will review it and may ask for additional information or documents. This process can take time, so patience is key. In some cases, the IRS may choose to examine your refund claim in more detail, potentially initiating an audit. If your claim is denied or partially allowed, you have the right to appeal this decision as well, just as you would in the case of an examination.
Handling an IRS examination, appeal, or refund claim can seem daunting, but IRS Publication 556 is a useful guide that clarifies each step and reinforces taxpayer rights. By understanding the process, gathering essential documentation, and knowing available options, taxpayers can manage examinations, appeals, and refund claims with greater ease. Being familiar with IRS procedures provides reassurance, helping taxpayers exercise their rights fairly. With thorough preparation and, if needed, professional support, navigating these interactions becomes more manageable. Whether facing an audit, disputing findings, or requesting a refund, Publication 556 serves as a trusted resource to protect and guide taxpayer rights.